KLI Publishes Analysis on the Non-Implementation of Constitutional Court Decisions, Calls for Criminal Accountability for Deliberate Non-Compliance

KLI Publishes Analysis on the Non-Implementation of Constitutional Court Decisions, Calls for Criminal Accountability for Deliberate Non-Compliance

KLI Publishes Analysis on the Non-Implementation of Constitutional Court Decisions, Calls for Criminal Accountability for Deliberate Non-Compliance

Pristina, 6 November 2026 – The Kosovo Law Institute (KLI), with the support of the Embassy of the Federal Republic of Germany in Pristina, today published its analysis, “The Non-Implementation of Constitutional Court Decisions,” at a roundtable discussion held at the European House in Pristina. The event was attended by members of the Kosovo Assembly, civil society representatives and other participants.

At the opening of the roundtable, KLI Senior Researcher Naim Jakaj presented the analysis’s main findings, noting that despite their binding constitutional force, Constitutional Court decisions in various cases have either not been implemented or have been implemented after considerable delays. He referred to the case of 572 workers at the Steel Factory in Ferizaj, the case of Fadil Hoxha and 59 citizens of Prizren, as well as cases concerning the Law on Salaries and the constitution of the Assembly.

Jakaj stressed that failure to implement Constitutional Court decisions infringes citizens’ rights, undermines legal certainty and erodes trust in state institutions. He also identified the absence of an explicit reference to Constitutional Court decisions in Article 394 of the Criminal Code as a problem, emphasising the need for clear criminal accountability in cases of deliberate and unjustified non-compliance.

Speaking about the Citizens’ Legislative Initiative, Jakaj said that 12,120 citizens had supported the proposal to amend and supplement the Criminal Code, which was submitted to the Assembly on 26 October 2026. He called on the Assembly to give serious consideration to the initiative, which also addresses criminal accountability for the use of public funds for electoral gain.

Deputy Speaker of the Assembly and PDK MP Vlora Çitaku expressed support for KLI’s initiative, stressing that Constitutional Court decisions must be implemented regardless of the political positions of the parties.
“With what authority can we tell the citizens of Kosovo to obey the law when the institution itself repeatedly violates it?” Çitaku said.

She noted that the PDK, too, is obliged to respect Constitutional Court decisions, and that the public has the right to hold every institution responsible for their non-implementation to account.
“When a public official entrusted with authority deliberately chooses to disregard a binding decision, the matter requires far more serious consideration than it has received so far,” Çitaku stated.

Çitaku also proposed establishing a parliamentary committee to request public reporting on the implementation of Constitutional Court decisions, identifying the responsible institutions, the actions required and the deadlines for fulfilling their obligations.

LDK MP Armend Zemaj stressed that Constitutional Court decisions are binding and must not be treated as recommendations.
“In a democratic state, Constitutional Court decisions should not be viewed as recommendations; they are binding,” Zemaj said.

He added that all political parties should take part in discussions concerning the state’s fundamental interests.

AAK MP Burim Ramadani said that impunity for the non-implementation of Constitutional Court decisions had become normalised, and that political debate about the decisions often attracts more attention than their implementation.
“It therefore seems that, in this respect, the political discussion about what the Constitutional Court has said carries more weight than the decision itself,” Ramadani said.

He also criticised the Government’s lack of public positions on the non-implementation of Constitutional Court decisions, describing this as a negative signal.

KLI Senior Researcher Gzim Shala stressed that failure to implement Constitutional Court judgments also means failure to respect the Constitution itself. According to Shala, international standards require these decisions to be implemented, but do not necessarily require non-implementation to be criminalised.

Shala explained that KLI had proposed amending Article 394 of the Criminal Code to limit criminal liability to cases of deliberate non-compliance, excluding delays or objective difficulties.
“What we hope and aim for, as we also stated in the analysis, is not to increase the number of criminal proceedings for the non-implementation of Constitutional Court judgments. Perhaps the most appropriate approach—and the greatest outcome we can achieve in this case—is precisely the absence of criminal proceedings,” Shala stated.

Representatives of the Vetëvendosje Movement (LVV) did not attend the roundtable.

In conclusion, KLI reiterated the importance of implementing Constitutional Court decisions and the need for the Assembly to consider the Citizens’ Legislative Initiative, with a view to strengthening the rule of law, legal certainty and institutional accountability.

The published report can be accessed at the following këtë link